Sweetheart
| Year | Name | Sorority |
|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Elena Herbstreit | Kappa Delta |
| 2011 | Hannah Fisher | Sigma Kappa |
| 2010 | Paula Hubler | Chi Omega |
| 2009 | Debbie Whitelock | Delta Zeta |
| 2008 | Debbie Whitelock | Delta Zeta |
| 2007 | Julie Cooper | Delta Zeta |
| 2006 | Kathryn Honegger | Chi Omega |
| 2005 | Julie Elliot | Chi Omega |
| 2004 | Nora Schack | Delta Zeta |
| 2003 | Cristin Patti | Kappa Delta |
| 2002 | Emily Cundiff | Chi Omega |
| 2001 | Beth Sherman | Delta Zeta |
| 2000 | Beth Sherman | Delta Zeta |
| 1999 | Becky Warner | Delta Zeta |
